Submitted by Jon on 2014/08/05 15:29
My file is old and TaskStart/TaskEnd were not working correctly with gantt charts.I removed the equations as Pierre instructed. I can now enter the start dates and end dates correctly. There are still problems.
 
1. Enter a TLI. No dates.
2. Create a sub item with start date and end date. The gantt bar displays correctly and the TLI (summary bar) updates to reflect the total duration of its child. But, the TaskDuration field is blank for both the TLI and this sub item
3. Now enter another sub as a sibling of the first sub. Enter start and end dates. Now create a dependency from the first child to the second child (sibling). See? The task duration field becomes populated for the second child when the dependency is created.
4. Optional but will underscore the point of this demonstration. Create more siblings with start and end dates and create dependencies. Again, the duration field is populated only after the dependencies are created.
5. Now refresh the grid and see what happens. For me, all the dependent items are gone and I am left with the TLI and the first child.
 
Jon

Comments

Hi Jon,
since I use the gantt a lot myself, I'm trying to reproduce these issues.
#1 : not sure what you mean here.
#2 Task duration seems to display the correct values. Maybe a conflicting equations ?
 
Will check others later.
 
-------------------------------------------------------
Windows 8.1
Sony Vaio S Series 13 (SVS131E21L)
Ram:8gb, CPU: Intel i5-3230M, 2.6ghz

Jon

2014/08/05 15:58

In reply to by Armando

#1. Just start a top level item to act as a summary for the project.
#2. The task duration displays ONLY if the item is a dependent. Otherwise, it is blank.
 
Refreshing the grid causes the dependents to vanish.
 
Jon
 
--
Sony Vaio Z, Intel Core i7, 8 GB RAM, 672 GB SSD
Windows 7 Professional 64 bit

Armando

2014/08/05 17:14

In reply to by Jon

My file is old and TaskStart/TaskEnd were not working correctly with gantt charts.I removed the equations as Pierre instructed. I can now enter the start dates and end dates correctly. There are still problems.
 
>1. Enter a TLI. No dates.
OK
 
>2. Create a sub item with start date and end date. The gantt bar displays correctly and the TLI (summary bar) updates to reflect the total duration of its child. But, the TaskDuration field is blank for both the TLI and this sub item
 
Ok. Actually, here, if I don't enter a date first in the TLI, no summarry bar appears. I need to enter some arbitrary task act. start/end. Then it works
Apart from that : no problem with durations. I do have a row equation/function taking care of that value though.
I've got a "TaskDuration" field that might be customized since there's a personnal row equation/function in there : TaskDurationCalc(TaskActEnd,TaskActStart)
 
 
>3. Now enter another sub as a sibling of the first sub. Enter start and end dates. Now create a dependency from the first child to the second child (sibling). See? The task duration field becomes populated for the second child when the dependency is created.
>4. Optional but will underscore the point of this demonstration. Create more siblings with start and end dates and create dependencies. Again, the duration field is populated only after the dependencies are created.
 
 
I'm not experiencing this problem. Probably because of my own equations. I'm not always relying on the gantt's own equations since they were not all there a few years ago.
 
That could actually become more of a problem : users using their own equations while the underlying equations are changing without notice.
 
 
 
>5. Now refresh the grid and see what happens. For me, all the dependent items are gone and I am left with the TLI and the first child.
 
Do you mean that they,re actually gone from the grid (would be a filter problem)? Or links have disappeared ? Here, everything is fine
 
disclaimer : still using v30
 
-------------------------------------------------------
Windows 8.1
Sony Vaio S Series 13 (SVS131E21L)
Ram:8gb, CPU: Intel i5-3230M, 2.6ghz

Jon

2014/08/05 17:21

In reply to by Armando

[quote=Armando]
>5. Now refresh the grid and see what happens. For me, all the dependent items are gone and I am left with the TLI and the first child.
 
Do you mean that they,re actually gone from the grid (would be a filter problem)? Or links have disappeared ? Here, everything is fine
 
disclaimer : still using v30
 
-------------------------------------------------------
Windows 8.1
Sony Vaio S Series 13 (SVS131E21L)
Ram:8gb, CPU: Intel i5-3230M, 2.6ghz
[/quote]
 
They disappear entirely from the grid. Not sure about the database - I have not checked. There is no filter active.
 
Why the disclaimer? Version 30 is the latest, no?
 
Jon
--
Sony Vaio Z, Intel Core i7, 8 GB RAM, 672 GB SSD
Windows 7 Professional 64 bit

Armando

2014/08/05 19:39

In reply to by Jon

[quote=Jon]
Why the disclaimer? Version 30 is the latest, no?
[/quote]
 
Eheh... I thought Pierre had already uploaded V31. Everything is so quick in this life, I always feel behind.
 
-------------------------------------------------------
Windows 8.1
Sony Vaio S Series 13 (SVS131E21L)
Ram:8gb, CPU: Intel i5-3230M, 2.6ghz

Hi Jon,
 
Is this issue resolved in the last version ?
 
Pierre

Jon

2014/08/16 19:26

In reply to by Pierre_Admin

 I am away right now and will not have the chance to confirm until Monday at the earliest.
 
Jon
 
--
Sony Vaio Z, Intel Core i7, 8 GB RAM, 672 GB SSD
Windows 7 Professional 64 bit

Jon

2014/08/18 16:17

In reply to by Pierre_Admin

[quote=Pierre_Admin]
Hi Jon,
 
Is this issue resolved in the last version ?
 
Pierre
[/quote]
 
Yes Pierre. It appears it has.
 
Jon
--
Sony Vaio Z, Intel Core i7, 8 GB RAM, 672 GB SSD
Windows 7 Professional 64 bit